In a previous post I said I would return to the star system beloved of review sites. Online
review sites almost always insist on every book being categorised in the range
of 5* (best book in the world) to 1* (worst book in the world).
I have a problem with that. If I was to put my mind to a
genuine categorisation of every book I read, then on the whole each would be
different. If compelled to stick with 1 to 5, then I want to be able to give
stars for lots of different reasons: how good a read was it, how involved did I
become, was the characterisation believable, was I lost in the fictional world,
did the facts stand up, was the background research meticulous and objective, how
was the opening page, did it grab me from the first sentence… I could go on.
And what a waste of time!
I also have a problem with allocating stars to a book that
did nothing for me. Do I say ‘Bored rigid from start to finish. 1*’? That doesn’t
seem fair if what bored me was that it was a historical novel and I wasn’t in
the mood for a historical novel because I’d just finished a sci-fi book. If I
knew the period well and could say, ‘Bored rigid by anachronisms and lack of
research,’ or if it was non-fiction and I could say, ‘Bored by lack of accuracy
and out of date research,’ that wouldn’t be so bad. At least those are valid objective
reasons.
But who am I to put off other readers with my 1* when it’s
based on a subjective judgement?
The other thing I won’t do is review a book I haven’t read,
and that takes care of the examples above because I wouldn’t have finished a
single one of those books. Why would I be ‘bored rigid from start to finish’ of
any book? I don’t go out of my way to seek out boring experiences.

“Really enjoyed the book but it came badly packaged – 2*”
I review books that I have enjoyed and with very few exceptions, I give them all their stars because I rarely
have an objective reason not to.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Thanks for your Comment. Due to escalating spam it is, unfortunately, being sent for moderation and should be uploaded shortly. We appreciate your patience.